Miss Lancaster County
1947    Mary Lou Wilmer
1948    Lucille Wright
1949    Joanne Weiler (Top 5)
1950    Senta von Ehrenfried
1951    Betsy Ettinger
1953    Evelyn Ay (Miss Pennsylvania, Miss America)
1958     Dorothy Ann Fletcher (Non-Finalist Talent Winner)
1959    Gini Heine (Top 5)
1960    Eleanor Johnson (1st Runner Up)
1961    Barbara Keener
1962    Mary Hill
1963    Donna Loar (Miss Pennsylvania)
1964    Gay Weiches
1965    Londa Boyd
1966    Stephanie Fauber
1967    Doris Lausch (Miss Pennsylvania)
1968    Gail Rabold (4th Runner Up)
1969    Pamela Nies (Top 10)
1970    Krista L. Burdock
1971    Gail Burnagord (Top 10)
1972    Joan Kling
1973    Tina Thomas (Miss Pennsylvania)
1974    Brenda Landis
1975    Marlene Frank (1st Runner Up)
1976    Gloria Longenecker (1st Runner Up)
1977    Lynn Carol Grote (Miss Pennsylvania)
1978    Jill Brown (Top 10)
1979    Carolyn Black (Miss Pennsylvania)
1980    Cyndi Taylor (4th Runner Up)
1981    Diane Boomsma (3rd Runner Up)
1982    Wendy Geesey
1983    Kathleen Ward (2nd Runner Up)
1984    Victoria Louise Boomsma (Top 10)
1985    Leisa Jacqueline Brown (Top 10)
1986    Kathy Lynn Keith
1987    Carla Jenkins (1st Runner Up)
1988    Rachel Farmer (3rd Runner Up)
1989    Raysa Acosta (Top 10)
1990    Jennifer Ann Graeber
1991    Danette Louise Caffrey
1992    Patricia Ann Ford (Top 10)
1993    Brenda Kaye Blevins
1994    Amy Louvise Renner (1st Runner Up)
1997    Leslie Shirk
1998    Catherine Elizabeth Walker
1999    Kathryn Elizabeth Zeager (3rd Runner Up)
2000    Erika Suzanne Smith
2016    Kayla Schneider
2017    Page Weinstein
2018    Marissa Witmer
2019    Courtney Armstrong (Non-Finalist Talent Winner)
2020    Kayla Myers* (Top 10)
2022    Miranda Moore (4th Runner Up)
2023    Victoria Vespico (2nd Runner Up)
2024    Noelle Schneider (Top 10)
2025    Madelyn Whitcraft (Non-Finalist Interview Award)

2026    Kathryn Davis
           * - Title held for two years

​

Miss Lancaster
1947    Mary Ellen Long
1948    Corinne Clemenceau

​

Miss Red Rose City
2016    Tiffany Shrom
2017    Marla Peifer (1st Runner Up)
2018    Jenna Martorana
2019    Brianna Kubishin
2021     Jenna Martorana
2022    Samantha Bretz (Top 10)
2023    AmandaGrace Krier (Top 10)
2024    Julianna Billings
2025    Samantha Roth

2026    Madelyn Whitcraft

​

Miss Commonwealth
2020    Lexi Bryant*
* - Title held for two years

​

Miss Heart of Lancaster
2021    Breanne Sensenig
2023    Elaine Ficarra
2024    AmandaGrace Krier
2025    Christina Herman (1st Runner Up)

2026    AK Hazel

​

Miss Southern Lancaster County

2026    Christina Herman